South Philly Pizza

Discover South Philly Pizza in New Philadelphia, OH, offering delicious pepperoni pizza, cheesy cheesesticks, flavorful salads, and wings. Enjoy our sweet sauce and quality food at 225 Commercial Ave SE. Call +1 330-339-3000 for dine-in or takeout!

Welcome to South Philly Pizza

Taste the Difference.

South Philly Pizza
South Philly Pizza
South Philly Pizza
South Philly Pizza

South Philly Pizza stands out in New Philadelphia as a local favorite for pizza lovers. Located conveniently at 225 Commercial Ave SE, this restaurant brings a taste of Philly to Ohio. Step inside to find a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for family dinners or gatherings with friends. The menu features everything from classic pepperoni pizzas to unique specialty pies, ensuring there's something for everyone. Savor the irresistible sweet sauce that keeps locals coming back for more.

Whether you crave a quick lunch or a hearty dinner, South Philly Pizza delivers satisfaction in each slice. Don't forget to try their famous cheesesticks or fresh salads, adding variety to your meal.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

225 Commercial Ave SE, New Philadelphia, OH 44663, United States

Phone

+1 330-339-3000

About

The Culinary Story

South Philly Pizza
South Philly Pizza
South Philly Pizza
South Philly Pizza

South Philly Pizza crafts authentic pizza with heart and soul. Located in the bustling area of New Philadelphia, the restaurant showcases a menu bursting with flavor and creativity.

Not only does South Philly Pizza focus on pizza, but it also serves an array of mouthwatering dishes. Chicken pizzas like White Chicken and Chicken Bacon Ranch provide a tasty twist on traditional pies. Cheesy garlic sticks serve as the perfect appetizer, drawing people in from the street. Salads like the Chef and Anti-Pasta introduce a refreshing crunch, ideal for health-conscious diners.

On busy nights, especially Fridays, the atmosphere buzzes with laughter and camaraderie. It's not uncommon to see families sharing a large pie while kids enjoy their favorite wings. The community really embraces South Philly Pizza as a gathering spot, whether it’s for game nights or casual dinners after a long week. Each element of the experience—from the staff’s friendliness to the aroma of freshly baked pizza—reflects a dedication to high-quality food and service.

The restaurant’s location at 225 Commercial Ave SE makes it easily accessible. Whether you live in the heart of New Philadelphia or in the outlying neighborhoods, a delicious pizza experience is just a short drive away. South Philly Pizza invites everyone to enjoy their rich flavors and sense of community every day.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday4-9 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday4-9 PM
  • Wednesday4-9 PM
  • Thursday4-9 PM
  • Friday4-10 PM
  • Saturday4-10 PM

South Philly Pizza offers a diverse menu that caters to all kinds of appetites. The variety of pizza sizes—from small 11-inch to large 15-inch—makes it easy to find the perfect fit for any occasion. Specialties like BBQ Chicken Pizza and Buffalo Chicken Ranch add flair to the traditional offerings. The side dishes, like garlic cheese sticks and fresh salads, complement the main courses perfectly.

With an average price of $7.35, dining here is budget-friendly.

The evening rush on Fridays is intense, reaching full capacity by 5 PM, so plan your visit accordingly. If you seek a quieter experience, consider visiting during off-peak hours such as Tuesday at 4 PM or Sunday at 6 PM. These times offer a relaxing vibe while enjoying delicious food.

South Philly Pizza

Approaching South Philly Pizza, a vibrant exterior catches the eye. The inviting entrance opens to a casual dining space with colorful decor that feels both familial and festive. Outdoor seating is available, making it a great spot to enjoy a meal in nice weather. Visitors often comment on the friendly vibe; locals frequently gather here, adding to the welcoming atmosphere. With a focus on community, the restaurant exhibits pride in being a beloved neighborhood establishment.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

This is probably my favorite pizza of all time. Every time I am in Ohio, I come here to get a large pepperoni. There is so much amazing pizza in Ohio, but this is what I order the most- by far. Service is always fast and kind! I've lived in Kentucky for the past several years, and South Philly Pizza is what I miss most about Ohio.

J
Jalen R.

Awesome place to get pizza and wings. Probably best round I would say. Sometimes it's a wait when they are busy but well worth the wait. They ladies here take there time to get your order perfect and at a great price. If I could eat here everyday I would. Some of the best cheeses that just melt in your mouth along with great sauce and bread emm just THE BEST.

J
Joeseph F.

Love South Philly pizza! Crunchy crust with a sweet sauce, always hot, fresh, so flavorful! Best place to pick up pizza on my way home from work!

R
Renee S.

South Philly Pizza is a Boltz family fave and has been for many years. Great service and exceptional food hands down!

K
Kristen B.

I have been enjoying South Philly Pizza for over 27 years. It is always a pleasant experience. It's a treat every time. I have had pizza from "gourmet" Italian places, brick fired ovens in South Beach, authentic New York style pizza, and everything in between. I believe a true testament to a good pie and good recipe is a pepperoni and cheese. Nothing else. No frills. I'll put South Philly up against any pizza, any place, any time. Life long favorite.

j
john b.

There deluxe pizza is the Best love there crust highly recommended!! And the salads are good too. Soooo Delicious.

L
Leigh R.